Refinance and Equity: Refinancing, Cash-Out and Home Equity Options
These five routes all use the home as security, and they divide on one question: are you replacing the mortgage you already have, or adding a second obligation alongside it?
That single distinction changes the rate you pay, what happens to the balance you have already repaid, and how much the whole arrangement costs over its full term.
Educational comparison only. Independent providers set their own eligibility, pricing and terms.
Replace, or add
What “refinance and equity” covers
Two of these routes replace your existing mortgage. Two sit alongside it as a second loan. Replacing the mortgage reprices the entire balance at today’s rate; adding a second obligation leaves the first one untouched.
That matters most when your current rate is lower than what is available now. A cash-out refinance does not borrow only the cash you take — it rewrites the whole loan, so the rate applies to everything you still owe, not just the new portion. A second-lien route leaves the original rate in place and prices only the new borrowing.
The second difference is how the money arrives. A cash-out refinance and a home equity loan both pay a fixed sum at closing. A HELOC lets you draw over a period, which suits costs that arrive in stages but makes the eventual repayment harder to predict.
A rate-and-term refinance takes no cash at all. It changes the rate, the term, the rate structure or the program — and nothing else.
Which route fits the goal
Start from what you are trying to achieve, then read that page before comparing offers.
Scroll the table sideways to see every column.
| Your goal | What that usually means | Start here |
|---|---|---|
| Change the rate, term or structure | What that usually meansReplacing the mortgage, taking no cash | Start hereRate-and-Term Refinance |
| Take cash and keep a single payment | What that usually meansReplacing the mortgage with a larger one | Start hereCash-Out Refinance |
| Take a fixed sum, keep the current mortgage | What that usually meansA second loan running alongside the first | Start hereHome Equity Loans |
| Draw funds in stages as costs arrive | What that usually meansA revolving second line, variable by default | Start hereHELOCs |
| Your existing rate is below today’s | What that usually meansA refinance would reprice the whole balance | Start hereCompare second-lien routes first |
| Not sure refinancing is worth the cost | What that usually meansThe break-even date decides it, not the rate | Start hereRefinance Options |
Compare the three in detail
Refinance Options
The overview: when refinancing makes sense, how to calculate the break-even point, and why a lower payment can cost more over the full term.
Rate-and-Term Refinance
Changes the rate, term, rate structure or program without taking cash. Compare closing costs against the break-even month before deciding.
Cash-Out Refinance
Replaces the mortgage with a larger one and pays the difference at closing. The new rate applies to the entire balance, not just the cash taken.
Home Equity Loans
A fixed sum as a second loan, with its own schedule, while the first mortgage continues unchanged. Check combined loan-to-value across both liens.
HELOCs
A revolving line drawn during a set period, then repaid. Usually variable. The payment at the end of the draw period is the figure worth modelling first.
What to compare, whichever route you take
The same figures decide cost across all five. Get them in writing before comparing anything:
- Total of all remaining payments, compared against keeping the current mortgage
- Closing costs, and the month at which savings overtake them
- Whether the term resets, and how many years that adds back
- The rate type — fixed, variable, or fixed for a period then variable
- For a HELOC, what the payment becomes once the draw period ends
- Combined loan-to-value across every lien on the property
- Prepayment terms, early-closure fees and any requirement to keep the line open
Your home secures every route on this page. A second lien is not a lesser obligation because it is second — missed payments can lead to foreclosure in the same way a first mortgage can. If the purpose is consolidating other debt, compare the total cost of the consolidated arrangement against what you owe now, and consider that unsecured balances become secured against the home.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does refinancing always reduce what I pay?
No. A refinance can lower the monthly payment while increasing the total paid, usually because the term restarts. Compare the total of all remaining payments under both arrangements, and include closing costs, before treating a lower payment as a saving.
What is the difference between a cash-out refinance and a home equity loan?
A cash-out refinance replaces your existing mortgage with a larger one, so the new rate applies to the whole balance. A home equity loan is a separate second loan; the first mortgage and its rate continue unchanged. Which costs less depends on your current rate, the amount, and both sets of terms.
My current rate is lower than rates today. Should I still refinance?
Refinancing reprices everything you still owe at the new rate, not just the amount you want to borrow. Where the existing rate is materially lower, a second-lien route may be worth comparing because it leaves the first mortgage alone. Run both and compare totals rather than rates.
What is a break-even point?
The month at which accumulated savings from the refinance exceed what it cost to arrange. If you may sell or refinance again before that month, the costs may not be recovered. See Refinance Options for how to calculate it.
Is a HELOC the same as a home equity loan?
No. A home equity loan pays a fixed sum with a set repayment schedule. A HELOC is a revolving line you draw from during a defined period, usually at a variable rate, with a different payment once that period ends.
Can I use the money for anything I want?
That depends on the provider and the product; some place conditions on use or require documentation for certain purposes. Tax treatment also varies with how funds are used and is not something ShopRates can advise on — speak to a qualified tax professional about your own circumstances.
What happens if I cannot keep up payments on a second lien?
The home secures it, so the consequences can include foreclosure. Contact the servicer early if payments become difficult — options vary by provider and situation, and they narrow as arrears build.
Does ShopRates decide whether I qualify?
No. ShopRates provides information and may connect you with independent providers. Each provider makes its own eligibility and pricing decisions.
Compare Refinance and Equity Routes on Total Cost
Tell us the goal, the amount range and your current mortgage position. ShopRates can organise the comparison and may connect you with independent providers. Each provider determines its own eligibility, pricing, fees, terms and funding schedule.
This is not an application, offer or commitment.