Rate-and-Term Refinance: Compare Payments, Costs and Terms
A rate-and-term refinance replaces your current mortgage with a new loan primarily to change the interest rate, repayment term, rate structure or loan program—not to intentionally withdraw substantial home equity.
The right comparison includes closing costs, points, mortgage insurance, the new balance and the repayment timeline. ShopRates helps homeowners understand those tradeoffs and explore options from independent providers.
Exploring options is not an approval, rate lock, savings estimate or commitment to lend.
Compare the complete transaction
Primary purpose
Change rate, term, rate type or loan program without planned substantial cash-out.
Does it replace the loan?
Yes. A new mortgage pays off the existing mortgage.
Can cash be received?
Program-specific limited proceeds may be permitted; definitions and limits vary.
Main decision test
Compare the new loan with keeping the current mortgage over the same time period.
Common costs
Provider, appraisal, title, settlement, recording, points, prepaids and escrow funding.
Approval
Credit, income, debts, assets, equity, title and property requirements apply.
How Does a Rate-and-Term Refinance Work?
The new provider underwrites a mortgage using the current property as collateral. At closing, the new loan pays off the existing mortgage and approved liens or transaction amounts. The homeowner begins repayment under the new note.
The transaction may change a fixed or adjustable rate, shorten or extend the term, move between eligible programs, or alter mortgage-insurance treatment. It does not erase the economic cost of the current loan or guarantee that the new terms are better.
The current mortgage remains active until payoff is completed. Continue required payments and confirm payoff and servicing transfer; do not assume an application or closing appointment stops the old obligation.
Direct answer: A rate-and-term refinance is a new mortgage transaction. Measure the benefit against the remaining balance, term and costs of the existing loan.
What Can Change?
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Element | Potential change | Decision question |
|---|---|---|
| Interest rate | Potential changeLower, higher or different structure | Decision questionDoes the benefit exceed costs and risks? |
| Term | Potential changeShorter, similar or longer | Decision questionHow do payment and total interest change? |
| Rate type | Potential changeARM to fixed, fixed to ARM or new ARM | Decision questionWhat are index, margin, caps and maximum payment? |
| Loan program | Potential changeEligible conventional/government path | Decision questionWhat fees, insurance and rules change? |
| Mortgage insurance | Potential changeMay begin, continue, change or end | Decision questionIs cancellation without refinance available? |
| Borrowers/title | Potential changeEligible borrower/title changes | Decision questionWhat underwriting, legal or tax issues apply? |
Rate-and-Term vs. Cash-Out
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Feature | Rate-and-term | Cash-out refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Primary purpose | Rate-and-termChange pricing, term, structure or program | Cash-out refinanceWithdraw eligible equity while replacing mortgage |
| New balance | Rate-and-termPayoffs and permitted transaction amounts | Cash-out refinanceIncludes intended equity proceeds |
| Cash back | Rate-and-termOnly amounts permitted by applicable definition | Cash-out refinancePlanned proceeds, subject to limits |
| LTV/pricing | Rate-and-termProgram-specific | Cash-out refinanceOften different maximum LTV/pricing |
| Risk focus | Rate-and-termCosts, term reset and qualification | Cash-out refinanceAll rate-term risks plus larger secured debt/equity reduction |
“No-cash-out,” “limited cash-out” and “rate-and-term” are not perfectly interchangeable across every program. The provider must classify the transaction under the selected rules.
Choose the Goal Before the Product
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Goal | Potential path | Evaluate |
|---|---|---|
| Lower rate | Potential pathNew fixed/ARM pricing | EvaluateAPR, points, costs, lock and break-even |
| Lower payment | Potential pathRate change or longer term | EvaluateWhether savings come from term extension |
| Faster payoff | Potential pathShorter term | EvaluateHigher required payment and liquidity |
| Payment stability | Potential pathARM-to-fixed | EvaluateCurrent caps versus new fixed cost |
| Remove insurance | Potential pathCancellation or eligible refinance | EvaluateCheapest path and new program costs |
| Change program | Potential pathFHA/VA/USDA/conventional path | EvaluateEligibility, fees, insurance and appraisal |
Keep Current Mortgage vs. Refinance
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Metric | Keep current | Proposed refinance |
|---|---|---|
| Principal balance | Keep currentCurrent payoff | Proposed refinanceNew amount including financed costs |
| Rate/APR | Keep currentNote rate; no new APR | Proposed refinanceNew rate and APR |
| Time remaining | Keep currentExact months left | Proposed refinanceNew term from closing |
| Monthly P&I | Keep currentCurrent scheduled amount | Proposed refinanceNew scheduled amount |
| Insurance | Keep currentCurrent PMI/MIP/fees | Proposed refinanceNew program treatment |
| Upfront cost | Keep currentNo new closing | Proposed refinanceCash costs, points and prepaids |
| Balance at year 3/5/7 | Keep currentCurrent amortization | Proposed refinanceNew amortization at same dates |
| Interest + costs | Keep currentRemaining-path cost | Proposed refinanceNew interest plus transaction costs |
Baseline rule: Never show a refinance offer without a keep-current column. Otherwise a lower payment can look beneficial while concealing a longer term or higher future balance.
Why a Lower Payment May Not Mean Savings
The monthly payment can fall because the rate is lower, the balance is lower, mortgage insurance changes, or the repayment term restarts. Only the complete comparison reveals the source.
If a mortgage with 18 years remaining is replaced by a new 30-year loan, the required payment may drop even if the interest-rate improvement is modest. The borrower gains near-term cash flow but adds scheduled years and may build equity more slowly.
Compare the balance and cumulative interest after the same future dates. Also compare the total cost if each loan is held to payoff, while recognizing that many borrowers sell or refinance earlier.
Break-Even Analysis
A simple break-even estimate divides eligible refinance costs by monthly payment savings. If transaction costs are $5,400 and monthly savings are $225, the simple break-even is 24 months.
Separate provider/title/appraisal costs and points from prepaid interest, taxes, insurance and escrow funding. Account for financed costs, mortgage insurance, balance differences and term changes.
When the new payment is higher because the term is shorter, use an equal-horizon comparison of interest, costs and principal instead of a monthly-savings break-even.
FORMULA
Simple break-even months = eligible refinance costs ÷ monthly payment savings. If savings are zero or negative, there is no simple payment break-even.
Equal-Horizon Test
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| At the same future date | Current mortgage | New mortgage |
|---|---|---|
| Total payments made | Current mortgageScheduled payments over period | New mortgageNew payments over identical period |
| Interest paid | Current mortgageCurrent amortization interest | New mortgageNew amortization interest |
| Transaction costs | Current mortgage$0 new refinance cost | New mortgageCash + financed costs + points |
| Principal reduction | Current mortgageBalance change | New mortgageBalance change |
| Remaining balance | Current mortgageProjected current balance | New mortgageProjected new balance |
| Net cash-flow difference | Current mortgageBaseline | New mortgagePayment difference less upfront cash |
Compare at the date you reasonably expect to sell, repay or refinance—not only at 30-year maturity. Run more than one horizon because plans change.
Closing Costs and Cash to Close
Rate-and-term refinancing usually has closing costs. These can include origination charges, discount points, credit report, valuation, flood determination, title and settlement services, recording, applicable taxes, prepaid interest, insurance and initial escrow funding.
A “no-closing-cost” offer generally uses a lender credit paired with a higher rate or finances eligible costs into the balance. The cost still exists.
Separate true transaction costs from prepaids and escrow deposits. A later escrow refund from the old servicer may offset part of the cash timing, but the amount and timing are not guaranteed.
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Treatment | Today | Over time |
|---|---|---|
| Pay costs in cash | TodayHigher cash to close | Over timeAvoid adding costs to principal |
| Finance eligible costs | TodayLower immediate cash | Over timeHigher balance and interest |
| Use lender credit | TodayOffsets eligible cost | Over timeUsually higher rate |
| Pay discount points | TodayHigher immediate cost | Over timeLower rate; needs recovery time |
Points, Credits, Rate and APR
The interest rate controls interest charged on principal. APR is a broader annualized cost measure including certain finance charges. Neither replaces review of payment, loan balance and cash to close.
Discount points generally buy a lower rate with more upfront cost. Lender credits generally offset eligible closing costs in exchange for a higher rate. Ask the same provider for multiple pricing choices on the same day.
Compare offers using the same loan amount, term and lock period. Confirm whether the rate is locked, the expiration date, extension fees and what assumptions can change pricing.
Qualification Requirements
A rate-and-term refinance is underwritten as a new loan. Providers may evaluate credit history and scores, stable qualifying income, recurring debts, assets, equity, occupancy, property type, title, insurance and payment history.
There is no universal minimum score, maximum DTI, minimum equity or reserve requirement across every refinance. Program rules and provider overlays vary. A current mortgage payment history does not guarantee approval.
Changes in employment, income, credit, assets, liens, title or property use can affect eligibility through closing. Keep information accurate and current.
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Factor | Review | Prepare |
|---|---|---|
| Credit | ReviewHistory, scores, utilization and recent events | PrepareReports and written explanations |
| Income | ReviewAmount, stability, continuance and calculation | PrepareSource-specific documents |
| Debt | ReviewRecurring obligations and housing expense | PrepareComplete liability disclosure |
| Assets | ReviewClosing funds and reserves when required | PrepareAll statement pages and transfer trail |
| Equity | ReviewAccepted value and existing liens | PrepareCurrent statements and lien data |
| Property/title | ReviewOccupancy, type, ownership and insurance | PrepareResolve issues early |
LTV and Appraisal
Loan-to-value compares the new first-mortgage amount with the property value accepted by the provider. Combined LTV adds qualifying subordinate liens. LTV affects program eligibility, pricing and mortgage insurance.
The provider may require an appraisal, alternative valuation or property-data review, or may permit a waiver in an eligible file. A waiver is not guaranteed. Do not order an appraisal independently unless the provider confirms acceptance.
A lower-than-expected value can change pricing, require cash to reduce the balance, preserve mortgage insurance or make the selected transaction unavailable.
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Measure | Calculation |
|---|---|
| LTV | CalculationNew first mortgage ÷ accepted property value |
| CLTV | CalculationAll secured loan balances ÷ accepted value |
| Equity | CalculationAccepted value − total liens |
| Cash needed to reach target LTV | CalculationPayoffs + costs − permitted new loan amount |
Program Paths
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Path | Use | Key limits |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional rate-and-term | UseChange eligible rate, term or program | Key limitsCredit, income, LTV, property and provider rules |
| FHA simple/rate-term refinance | UseEligible refinance into FHA | Key limitsFHA appraisal, insurance, occupancy and underwriting rules |
| FHA Streamline | UseEligible existing FHA loan | Key limitsSeasoning, payment history and net tangible benefit; restricted cash back |
| VA IRRRL | UseEligible existing VA-backed loan | Key limitsSeasoning, recoupment/net benefit and VA requirements |
| USDA refinance | UseEligible USDA refinance path | Key limitsAgency, property, loan and borrower requirements |
| Jumbo/portfolio | UseHigher balance or provider-held program | Key limitsProvider-specific reserves, equity and property rules |
Conventional loans → · FHA Streamline Refinance → · VA IRRRL → · USDA refinance → · Jumbo loans →
Streamline guardrail: Streamline does not mean automatic approval, no costs, no appraisal in every file, no income review in every circumstance or unlimited cash back.
Mortgage Insurance
Before refinancing solely to remove mortgage insurance, ask the current servicer whether cancellation is available without a new loan. Conventional PMI cancellation and termination rights depend on applicable rules and the loan.
Moving from FHA to conventional may change monthly insurance, but compare the new rate, APR, closing costs, equity requirement and remaining FHA insurance. A new conventional loan can require PMI if LTV is high.
VA-backed loans do not use monthly mortgage insurance but may include a funding fee unless exempt. USDA loans use guarantee-fee structures.
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Current loan | First action | Refinance test |
|---|---|---|
| Conventional with PMI | First actionRequest servicer cancellation criteria | Refinance testDoes total benefit exceed costs? |
| FHA with MIP | First actionCheck duration based on loan facts | Refinance testCompare FHA vs conventional complete costs |
| VA-backed | First actionCheck IRRRL and funding-fee status | Refinance testVerify recoupment and net benefit |
| USDA | First actionCheck agency refinance eligibility | Refinance testCompare annual/upfront fees and new terms |
ARM-to-Fixed and Term Changes
An ARM-to-fixed refinance trades future adjustment exposure for a fixed note rate. Compare the current ARM’s index, margin, adjustment schedule and caps with the new fixed-rate costs.
A shorter term may reduce lifetime interest and accelerate equity while increasing the required payment. A longer term can reduce the payment while extending repayment.
A fixed-to-ARM refinance may lower the initial rate but introduces adjustment risk. Review the first adjustment, periodic and lifetime caps, floor, qualifying rate and maximum possible payment.
When Refinancing May Not Fit
- You expect to sell or refinance again before costs are recovered.
- The payment falls mainly because the loan term restarts.
- Closing costs or points erase the expected benefit.
- A prepayment penalty, recapture, assistance lien or tax consequence changes the economics.
- The new loan adds mortgage insurance or a riskier ARM structure.
- You must deplete emergency reserves to close.
- A current-servicer cancellation or modification path solves the goal more cheaply.
- The provider cannot document the assumptions behind a promotional rate.
Sunk-cost rule: Do not refinance merely because money has already been spent on an application or appraisal. Re-evaluate when the rate, costs, value or terms change.
Process
- Define the measurable goal and expected holding period.
- Collect the current statement, note, payoff estimate and exact remaining term.
- Estimate value, liens, LTV and available cash.
- Review credit, income, debts, assets, title and insurance.
- Request comparable options from multiple providers close in time.
- Receive official Loan Estimates for the same scenario.
- Run break-even and equal-horizon comparisons against keeping the loan.
- Select rate/points/credits and understand lock terms.
- Complete valuation, title and underwriting; continue old-loan payments.
- Review Closing Disclosure, close when satisfied, observe applicable rescission rights and confirm payoff.
Document Checklist
Scroll sideways to see the full table.
| Category | Prepare |
|---|---|
| Current mortgage | PrepareStatement, note if available, payoff/escrow details and subordinate liens |
| Identity/title | PrepareID, vesting and trust/divorce/entity documents as applicable |
| Income | PreparePay records, W-2/1099/K-1 forms, returns when required, award letters |
| Self-employment | PrepareBusiness returns, P&L, balance sheet and statements |
| Assets | PrepareAll pages of statements; deposit and transfer trail |
| Liabilities | PrepareMortgage, lease, support and recurring obligations |
| Property | PrepareInsurance, tax, HOA, lease and improvement records |
| Explanations | PrepareEmployment gaps, credit events, large deposits and ownership changes |
Comparison Worksheet
Scroll sideways to see the full worksheet.
| Field | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
|---|---|---|---|
| Balance/new amount | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Rate / APR | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Term remaining/new term | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Fixed or ARM details | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Points / credits | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Closing costs | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Cash to close | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Monthly P&I | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Mortgage insurance | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Total monthly payment | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Simple break-even | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Balance at year 5 | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Interest + costs at year 5 | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Lock expiration | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
| Penalty/balloon | Keep current | Offer A | Offer B |
Use the same loan amount, term assumptions, lock period and date. A complete comparison includes the existing mortgage—not just competing refinance offers.
Right of Rescission
Federal law generally provides a right to cancel certain refinances secured by a principal dwelling until midnight of the third business day after the last of consummation, delivery of the required notice, or delivery of all material disclosures. Saturdays generally count; Sundays and legal public holidays generally do not.
Exceptions apply, including aspects of certain same-creditor transactions and property that is not the principal dwelling. Follow the official notice for the transaction and obtain legal guidance when needed.
Rescinding the refinance does not cancel the existing mortgage. Continue required payments on the existing obligation.
CFPB rescission guide →
Regulation Z §1026.23 →
Legal guardrail: Never state that every refinance has three days to cancel. Coverage, exceptions and timing depend on the transaction and document delivery.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a rate-and-term refinance?
It is a new mortgage that replaces the current loan primarily to change the interest rate, repayment term, rate structure or loan program without intentionally withdrawing substantial equity.
Is rate-and-term the same as no-cash-out refinance?
The terms overlap, but program definitions can differ. A provider must classify the transaction under the selected program’s rules.
Can I receive cash from a rate-and-term refinance?
Some programs permit limited amounts resulting from payoff or closing adjustments. The purpose is not substantial equity withdrawal, and permitted amounts vary.
Does a lower refinance payment always save money?
No. The payment may fall because the term restarts or extends. Compare closing costs, future balances and interest over equal time periods.
How do I calculate refinance break-even?
Divide eligible refinance costs by monthly payment savings for a simple estimate. Also account for financed costs, term changes, insurance and future balances.
What closing costs apply?
Costs may include provider charges, points, valuation, title, settlement, recording, prepaids, insurance and escrow funding.
Is a no-closing-cost refinance free?
Generally no. Eligible costs may be offset by a higher rate and lender credit or added to the balance when permitted.
Do I need an appraisal?
Not always. A provider may require an appraisal or alternative valuation or may permit a waiver. A waiver is not guaranteed.
Can I refinance from an ARM to a fixed rate?
Yes, if eligible. Compare the current ARM’s adjustment terms with the new fixed rate, APR, fees and break-even period.
Can refinancing remove mortgage insurance?
Sometimes, but first check whether the current servicer offers cancellation without refinancing. New loan insurance rules and costs apply.
What credit score is required?
There is no universal score across all rate-and-term programs and providers. Credit is evaluated with income, debts, equity, property and the complete file.
Can I cancel after signing?
Certain refinances secured by a principal dwelling generally have a three-business-day rescission right, but exceptions and detailed timing rules apply.
Compare Rate-and-Term Refinance Options
Options
Start with the mortgage you already have. Then compare new terms, costs and future balances from independent providers.
No approval, rate, savings, appraisal or closing is guaranteed.
Sources
- CFPB mortgage key terms — consumerfinance.gov/consumer-tools/mortgages/answers/key-terms
- CFPB Loan Estimate — consumerfinance.gov/owning-a-home/loan-estimate
- CFPB Closing Disclosure — consumerfinance.gov/owning-a-home/closing-disclosure
- CFPB points and credits — consumerfinance.gov/ask-cfpb
- HUD refinance programs — hud.gov/hud-partners/single-family-refinance
- VA home loans — benefits.va.gov/homeloans
This page provides general educational information and is not individualized financial, legal, tax or credit advice. ShopRates is not a lender or mortgage broker and does not make credit decisions. Programs, approval standards, rates, fees, values and terms vary and can change. Obtain official Loan Estimates and transaction-specific guidance. A mortgage is secured by the home and failure to make required payments can result in foreclosure.